The small attacker shone in a tense DStv Premiership match at the FNB Stadium on Sunday, as the two sides shared the spoils with a 1-1 draw.
"I've seen a lot from my team, and I believe Peter Shalulile is deserving of Player of the Year," Mngqithi remarked.
To be honest, so do Themba Zwane and AJ [Andile Jali].
"I too believe Keagan Dolly is deserving. He had a fantastic season as well, and he deserves it.
Based on his previous performances, I believe a young player may have lit up the stage this season.
"The young Kaizer Chiefs central midfielder Ngcobo. I believe that if he had made more appearances this season, he could have provided a lot more.
"However, those I've named all deserve to win the Player of the Season honor."
Manqoba Mngqithi, the co-coach of Mamelodi Sundowns, has heaped admiration on young Kaizer Chiefs midfielder Nkosingiphile Ngcobo.